Sister My Sister Bake Shop in Big Bear Lake

Sister My Sister Bake Shop in Big Bear Lake
4.5 / 5
50 reviews

40191 Big Bear Blvd, Big Bear Lake, CA 92315, Big Bear Lake

Overview

Cuisine
  • American

Restaurant Hours

Monday

08:00 - 17:00

Tuesday

08:00 - 17:00

Wednesday

08:00 - 17:00

Thursday

00:00 - 17:00

Friday

00:00 - 17:00

Do you have coffee

Yes they do!

Do you have cinnamon rolls

The best I have ever had! Their cinnamon rolls are to die for

Do you bake 3 kings cake?

You have to do a special order for it

Hi. I'm visiting at Christmas and looking for Gingerbread men and women even Santa or Rudolph themed and decorated large cookies. Gingerbread and icing. Will you have this type of treat?

Your best bet would be to call the store directly. The girls in there are super nice !

Do you have whole cakes for purchase, without preorder?

It is very limited but no matter what time I've gone in there's always been two cakes. I love this bakery.

Do you have bagels?

They have amazing pastries. No bagels.

Do they have macaroons?

She makes a variety actually. My favorite are the lavender and Earl grey tea! But she does traditional like caramel, coffee etc as well. I've had about 8 different flavors I would say

Review

Add rating restaurant:
Sister My Sister Bake Shop
YV
Yevgeniya Vinichenko
google
11.21.2024
5/5

Small place but very nice and cozy. They have a lot of maffins, croissants, a little of cheese cake sold by portions. Fresh and tasty.

Sister My Sister Bake Shop
Rd
Romy dela Rosa
google
10.16.2018
5/5

It was very good. Small place but fantastic.

Sister My Sister Bake Shop
CL
Cynthia Lee
google
10.10.2018
5/5

Can't wait to try their bread pudding next time. Everything is delicious and beautiful

Sister My Sister Bake Shop
MC
Mary Canchola
google
09.03.2018
5/5

Celebrating my granddaughter’s 21st birthday I wanted to get a cake for the celebration. Not being familiar with Big Bear I read reviews on this bakery. It did not disappoint!! I picked the cookies n’ cream cake. It was 4 layers tall & yummy! I called 2 days ahead & they said they couldn’t do anything fancy because of the short time, but would write Happy 21st Birthday & her name. I asked if there was anyway they could put a couple of sunflowers (her favorite) & she said no & was sorry. I accepted that since I was the procrastinator in ordering. I picked the cake up at the agreed on time & it was ready AND they added a few sunflowers!! I was so excited to see the cake!! Everyone gave the cake a thumbs up on flavor, freshness, & decorating. Thank you Sister My Sister Bake Shop! You really came thru! And my daughter & I enjoyed meeting your mother who is very proud of both of you!! If I’m in Big Bear again I will definitely go there for some scrumptious looking goodies!!

Sister My Sister Bake Shop
PO
Patricia O'Connor
google
08.27.2018
5/5

Best Strawberry Cupcake I have ever had!!!

Sister My Sister Bake Shop
MH
Marissa Hart
google
08.19.2018
5/5

Beautiful and delicious cake/dessert table for my wedding. Lucy had everything set up and delivered to the venue on the day of the wedding, it was perfect and stress free! Highly recommend.

Sister My Sister Bake Shop
YC
Yvonne Cervantez
google
08.16.2018
5/5

Friday morning everything I need fresh and a great variety

Sister My Sister Bake Shop
WH
Willie Hardwick
google
08.12.2018
5/5

Honestly if I could give them 10 starts I would. I've been ordering cakes from Lucy (one of the owners) for 2 years now and I'm never let down. She has done every birthday cake I've ever needed and even my sister in laws wedding cake. She makes the most high quality cakes and frosting from scratch. If you are looking for a custom cake here is the place to go for any events you have.

Sister My Sister Bake Shop
GV
Gianna Vasquez
google
08.09.2018
5/5

Sister My Sister Bake Shop is hands down the BEST bakery I've ever been to! Being a Wedding Photographer, I've tasted a looot of cakes and treats, but none have come close to the delicious treats Lucy + her team makes! Lucy is such a hard worker and puts so much love into everything she creates. I tell everyone who comes to visit Big Bear that Sister My Sister is a MUST stop! From her moist cupcakes, mouthwatering pie bars (mixed berry is my favorite), fresh bread, better than Cinnabon cinnamon rolls and all the beautiful/creative creations, I am always impressed! She even has delicious gluten-free items! The prices are extremely reasonable, considering the high quality. The atmosphere there is always warm and welcoming. 10/10 recommend this place to anyone looking for yummy treats for their wedding/any event or just need a sweet-tooth fix! Love you Lucy!!!

Sister My Sister Bake Shop
EC
Erika Castellanos
google
07.12.2018
5/5

Cute little bakery to grab a coffee and pastry

Sister My Sister Bake Shop
SL
Sylvia Lobato
google
06.01.2018
2/5

Kinda bland didn't even finish the deserts and customer service could be a lot better to. Honestly when she was bothered by our questions after we told her it was our first time we normally just walk out, should have on this place

Sister My Sister Bake Shop
KN
Kimberly N
google
05.19.2018
2/5

Be careful of the safe food handling practices at this place. I went on July 4th. The girl working used the same glove to pick up food directly, open doors, take and exchange money and run her hand through her hair. I watched and she didn't change her gloves for the next customer either. It makes me wonder what other things happen when the food is made. No food item is worth getting sick over.

Sister My Sister Bake Shop
SS
Sara Seaman
google
05.15.2018
5/5

I had two graduation cakes made at Sister My Sister Bake Shop. The finished products were absolutely beautiful and very very tasty!! You will never have to worry about the finish product, the artistic talent is out of this world!! We love this bake shop and will always use them!!

Sister My Sister Bake Shop
BS
Brandice Schumacher
google
05.06.2018
5/5

Delicious treats for everybody. We went in and got pretty much one of everything. Nothing disappointed us. If you're in the area stop in and check out this locally owned shop 😁

Sister My Sister Bake Shop
SG
Shishir Govindan
google
04.19.2018
5/5

Simple amazing! Got lemon raspberry, black forest, strawberry. Truly one the best cup cakes I've ever tasted! I would visit the area just to be back here. Thanks you! ✌️🙂

Sister My Sister Bake Shop
SJ
S Johnston
google
03.10.2018
5/5

The best bakery in Big Bear.

Sister My Sister Bake Shop
KC
Kathy C
google
01.26.2018
5/5

Delicious lemon bars and brownies! Looking forward to trying other treats on our next visit. Staff was also friendly.

Sister My Sister Bake Shop
FG
Frank Garcia
google
11.11.2017
5/5

Awesome establishment, great service and even better baked goods. Would definitely return and recommend to friends and family. If you're ever in the Lake Big Bear area, you got to stop by.

Sister My Sister Bake Shop
AR
Angela Romero
google
11.08.2017
5/5

It's a small bakery but their goods are huge on taste. Baked fresh daily from their cakes, cookies, pastries, and pies, absolutely yummy. Oh, and their customer service outstanding.

Sister My Sister Bake Shop
WS
Wendy Steffensen
google
09.20.2017
5/5

One of the cupcakes didn't even make it down the street before we inhaled it! Absolutely amazing!!

Sister My Sister Bake Shop
BS
B S
google
09.17.2017
5/5

Tasty pastries. Especially enjoyed the peanut butter cream sandwich.

Sister My Sister Bake Shop
AE
Angela Elizabeth
google
08.19.2017
5/5

Love this bakery! Always friendly and the baked goods are fresh and sooo delicious!

Sister My Sister Bake Shop
ks
kk sbard
google
07.11.2017
5/5

Loved their tasty muffins! Also liked the cherry cheesecake and cupcakes. Wouldn't buy the cookies again. Nice little variety of baked goods but can't count on them having what you came back for on another day (muffins).

Sister My Sister Bake Shop
PY
P-Dub Ya
google
06.20.2017
5/5

The best bakery for sweets up in Big Bear!!!

Sister My Sister Bake Shop
JJ
J. J.
google
05.25.2017
5/5

Decided to try this place and oh my god, wonderful bakery goods.. try everything!!

Sister My Sister Bake Shop
RT
Robbyn Tucker
google
05.16.2017
5/5

Love the bake goods at Sister my Sister. Delicious and well done. Everything I've ever tried there has been really tasty. I love that we have this bakery up here. But, it took me thru tourist traffic 1 hour and 40 minutes to get my delicious baked goods today. Well worth the trip. I will enjoy every bite.

Sister My Sister Bake Shop
AE
Amanda Erickson
google
05.11.2017
5/5

DELICIOUS BAKED GOODS!! I had a lemon bar which was pretty much the best I've ever had. Lucy made my sister's wedding cake and each tier was a different flavor and the cake was absolutely gorgeous. The honey lavender cake was divine! Like nothing I've ever had and I wish I had some right now! On top of the delicious treats, the staff are friendly and wonderful!

Sister My Sister Bake Shop
NM
Nicholle M
google
05.03.2017
5/5

Wonderful, quaint dessert place! The desserts are a delicious, guilty pleasure. I always come here at least twice during my stay in Big Bear and on my way back home. It is very much worth the trip!

Sister My Sister Bake Shop
kp
kyle polich
google
04.12.2017
5/5

Best bakery we found in BB

Sister My Sister Bake Shop
RL
Randi Lamey
google
03.26.2017
5/5

Lucy was so great with me and my now husband. She was very precise with taking my order, and her price was extremely reasonable. Most importantly, her cake was the best tasting cake I ever had. I ordered a two-tierd cake for my wedding with strawberry on top and vanilla on the bottom and couldn't be happier with my choice. BUT, the best part was the cupcakes! We had several different flavors and the cupcakes were apparently the best part of my wedding! They didn't taste store bought at all! They were so delicious, moist, and you can taste the different style of how Lucy mixes her ingredients. Lucy and her family business is a botique bakery that you can trust. She is truly an artist. Thank you Sister My Sister bake shop!! You all are Big Bears best kept secret :-) Love, Randi

Sister My Sister Bake Shop
LP
Lex Parker
google
02.26.2017
5/5

If in Big Bear lake don’t miss this delicious bakery! The cupcakes are to die for as are the scones...

Sister My Sister Bake Shop
NP
Nacho Picasso
google
02.13.2017
3/5

Finally tried this place after passing it daily.. First impression, the cookies on the counter were amazing; and overall, the service was excellent. We special ordered a cheesecake for the holidays. Picked it up and everything looked yummy. But.. We were let down. At best, the cheesecake was marginal. Very expensive for what I thought would be an outstanding cake, but unfortunately wasn't. It's too bad as I had high hopes for this bakery. I may be back to try something else, this just happened to be my first experience here.

Sister My Sister Bake Shop
SK
Susannah Kelemen
google
01.27.2017
5/5

This place is so charmng. Its great if your looking for something basic like a cookie or something over the top like a wedding cake. The pastries are delicious and not to mention the lavender cupcakes are devine with a cup of tea at 2 in the afternoon!

Sister My Sister Bake Shop
LA
Lourdes Aguilar
google
01.13.2017
5/5

This bakery was able to accommodate my friend with her wedding cake in a short notice and the taste was very good.

Sister My Sister Bake Shop
SP
Suzy Person
google
11.08.2016
5/5

Thank you for doing our wedding cake! It was so delicious and all the guests loved it, even my brother who doesn't uaually care for cake said it was amazing. They went above and beyond in making sure it was ready in time. Thank you again!

Sister My Sister Bake Shop
AC
Anthony Charles
google
10.25.2016
5/5

I'm from out of town, but spent a weekend in Big Bear for a couple birthdays and ordered a cake with a Peruvian flag on it. This isn't an easy flag to make but it came out perfect - everyone loved it and I was very impressed. Tasted great as well, I would definitely recommend this bake shop.

Sister My Sister Bake Shop
RB
Rubi Bravo
google
10.21.2016
5/5

I ordered my mom's 50th birthday cake here and I'm so glad I did. I always see the amazing cakes that Lucy makes on their Instagram account and my moms cake was just as amazing. The cake was gorgeous and SOOO DELICIOUS! Highly recommend

Sister My Sister Bake Shop
as
aaron sipp
google
10.06.2016
5/5

The Cheesecake is freshly made and extremely tasty. Great place for a little sweet tooth craving.

Sister My Sister Bake Shop
JF
Juan F
google
08.26.2016
5/5

Some of the best pastries i have ever had. Me and my wife had the cheesecake and cinnamon roll with cream cheese frosting, it was delicious!! The prices were great and the food was very fresh. The staff was veey attentive and friendly. We will definately be returning.

Sister My Sister Bake Shop
TM
Tevita Moce
google
08.20.2016
5/5

Love their cinnamon roll

Sister My Sister Bake Shop
MF
Marisol F
google
07.09.2016
5/5

We stopped in to try this cute bakery . It was so delicious we were amazed and in love with pastries. We had a cinamon roll and a slice of cherry cheesecake. Wow, wow amd WOW! Best cinamom roll witj cremcheese deostimg i have ever had. And the made feom scratch cheescake is to die for. The treats jere are dedimtlt made with loce amd attention. Nothing was too sweet it was just right! Don't think about it just stop in and see for your self! And Hilda was amazimg and so sweet! I wanted to go right back and buy more treats! It was really that good!!

Sister My Sister Bake Shop
SW
Shelby Wright
google
07.03.2016
5/5

Hands damn best customer service!!! Amazing deserts! And the amazing sisters! Highly recommend this place! Amazing! Call because they dont always close at 6 which is amazing they stay open for you which is super nice of them!

Sister My Sister Bake Shop
SM
Susan McWilliams
google
06.21.2016
5/5

We stopped in during our Big Bear vacation and fell in love with their “honey lavender” cupcakes! So delicious!

Sister My Sister Bake Shop
ME
Marie Escobar
google
05.21.2016
3/5

The staff was friendly cupcakes were great but the cinnamon rools were very dry and old. The sticky buns tasted stale and dry. I love the presentation but I tried a few other items and only the cupcakes were great.

Sister My Sister Bake Shop
BD
Beau Daniel
google
05.18.2016
5/5

Amazing! Extremely flavorful, best baked goods I think I have ever had. EXPENSIVE, but worth it. I'll very likely be back. I had ordered almost one of everything and was a fan of every item.

Sister My Sister Bake Shop
SW
Synaptic Wanderer
google
04.11.2016
5/5

If you love peanut butter, you have to come here. There's also a banana split cupcake, which is something I've never seen before, and the woman at the counter is wonderful!

Sister My Sister Bake Shop
DM
Destiny McKeever
google
03.21.2016
5/5

Real baked goods. This little shop bakes from scratch and from the heart. Small selection of desert staples and definitely worth a try. Wish they had a tea pot selection so you could really relax and enjoy your treat.

Sister My Sister Bake Shop
MT
Masha Talantova
google
02.02.2016
5/5

Very nice and clean bakery, highly recommended

Sister My Sister Bake Shop
JC
Jan Crane
google
01.18.2016
5/5

Delicious baked goods. Snowballs are the best. Aka wedding cookies.

Sister My Sister Bake Shop
SP
Sabrina Pina
google
01.10.2016
5/5

Very nice staff and yummy baked goods

Your question has been sent.

Expect an answer!

Thank!

Your review has been submitted.

Order food

Reservation

Want to order over the phone?

Call 19098780878

Thank you for being with us!

We will call you back!